1) Hissing.
Hissing is frequently done in the USA when the audience wants to show the dancer
appreciation, but it is actually considered an insult in the Middle East. As we
are a Middle Eastern art form, it is best NOT to do this as it shows ignorance
of the culture which spawned the dance. If you have a mixed audience of
Americans and Middle Easterners, this could also be quite confusing.
2) The dance started
out as a form of seduction in the harems.
First of all, "harem" is our pronunciation for the Arabic word "ha- RAHM'" which
means "forbidden." Muslim societies were (and some still are) segregated, so the
harem is the place where women lived that is forbidden to men. Although many
women may have congregated there, most were relatives (sisters, mothers,
daughters), so there wasn't likely much competition for the FATHER, BROTHER, or
SON. Even in rare instances where there were large harems full of captive
non-relatives, the "sultan" would not enter to choose his partner based on who
danced the sexiest. The partner was most likely chosen by the head wife or the
sultan's mother, so it was most advantageous to schmooze her.
3) Veils (Salome,
Ishtar, etc). Salome and the 7
veils is a myth created by Oscar Wilde, then expanded on by Richard Strauss,
Isadora Duncan, Ruth St. Denis, and others. There is no evidence that this
happened in history. I know that the Bible says that an unnamed dancer performed
for Herod, then asked for the head of John the Baptist in return, but it never
says that she used veils or described her movements in any way that would lead
one to believe that she belly danced.
Further, the
association of Innana/Ishtar with belly dancing with veils is another stretch
that is similar to that above. The story is that Innana had to remove a garment
at each of the gates of Hell in order to go further. The story never says she
danced, that she removed veils, or used seduction.
Although veils are
used in the Middle East today, they are an entrance prop and are not “danced
with” the way they are here. Veil dancing originated in the west and is a purely
western thing. Period.
4) Sword dancing was
started by Gypsies who used soldiers' swords to entertain them. There is one historic painting that depicts a
dancer (Ghawazee?) with a sword on her head, but there is no evidence that this
was ever a widespread practice. It is NOT considered authentic or folklore.
However it is enjoyed by Arabs and is frequently requested, so go ahead and use
sword for ethnic audiences.
5) A belt and bra is
considered the "traditional" belly dance costume.
Middle Eastern women are modest and would not have worn anything that showed a
bare midriff. This is a Hollywood invention. They adopted the idea to meet
western demands for what they envisioned. Other costume pieces (such as a choli,
tassel belts, etc.) that are frequently worn in the west are not authentic
either. While it is true that some women who danced earned coins that they
subsequently sewed on to their clothing, this never was done in a fashion that
resembled a coin belt or bra.
6) The dance is not
meant to be sexy. As a therapist, I
often recommend belly dancing for women who are recovering from sexual assault
and domestic violence as a means to recover their power. This means ALL their
power. People are sexual beings, and there is nothing wrong with being sexual.
There is something wrong
with exploiting sex or being disrespectful. In other words, sensual and sexual
are okay. Slutty is not. What you do in private is up to you, but when you are
in public, you should represent yourself and the dance in a respectable manner.
When you are true to yourself and respectful of yourself, your audience, and the
dance, you are most likely on the right track.
7) “Gypsy” dancing.
The correct name for Gypsy is Rom, Roma,
or Romany. Other names used by the Gypsy people to describe themselves are: Cigano, Tsigani, Tzigane, and
Zigeuner. Some tribes do refer to themselves as “Gypsy”, but some consider this an offensive term. Not
all Rom share the same language or the same culture. They are spread throughout
a wide geographic area, so unless you are specifically describing which tribe
you are representing when you do a “Gypsy” dance, and the work is based on
research, you are doing fakelore. The most common term for fakelore pieces is
“Fantasy Gypsy”. There is nothing wrong with Fantasy Gypsy, but please identify
it as such so that ignorance is not spread to your audience. The dances, dress,
and music used by Russian, Spanish, Egyptian, and Turkish Rom will all be
different.
8)
Goddess and Pharaonic dancing.
While there are many
historical references to dancing in Pharaonic times and as part of temple
worship that occurred in the Middle East, there is no evidence that this was
belly dance as we know it today or a precursor to belly dance. That
knowledge is lost in antiquity. “Goddess dancing” and “Pharanoic dancing” is
like “Gypsy dancing.” It’s a made-up vision of what the creator thinks it
was like. It’s fakelore, not folklore.
9)
“History.”
Beware of “history.”
There are many things that are written in seemingly scholarly places that are
either flat out untrue or are distorted. Sometimes the distortion happens
because the lens that the information is filtered through colors the
interpretation. Sometimes the information is true for one culture, but not all.
Sometimes it’s pure fantasy. It’s very difficult to generalize because there are
a variety of cultures within the Arab, Coptic, Jewish, and Rom people that
inhabit the area in and around the Middle East. What’s true for one is not true
for all.